Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Simon's avatar

Thanks for this Owen, great analysis.

As much as Reed’s wonderful strike will get plaudits, Jimenez’ touch for the Wilson goal was my highlight, to be able to see the opportunity and implement was absolutely elite level.

I hope at the end of the season that number of apologies from Howard Webb supplants GD as the decisive factor if teams are level on points, we are due another.

Expand full comment
CinCity Noir's avatar

Great game report!

That VAR call was the definition of how it's NOT supposed to function. There certainly was no "clear and obvious error" to overturn the call on the field, plus, I believe, semi-automated. Plus, the VAR judgment was flat-wrong. A big problem with VAR is frame accuracy. In realtime, the cut of the grass told the tale. Video runs 25fps in the UK, 30fps in the US, meaning one frame can make the difference between on- and off-side, and in this case, that one frame shift was glaring. BUT, again, not grounds for a judgment of "clear and obvious error."

Jimenez deserves knighthood for his hard work to the benefit of the English game!

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?