Having been going to the Cottage for 30 years, I feel a good dose of gallows is central to understanding what it really means to be a Fulham fan.
That walk back through Bishop’s Park before drowning your sorrows, on a cold evening after United have just scored yet another last-minute goal amid their annual crisis. All you can do is shake your head and laugh: it’s happened again.
We all shared this déjà vu after Jacob Murphy scored yet another doozy against us. As one who likes to appreciate the obscure, I started piecing together a bête noire XI for my sins.
Translated from the French as ‘black beast’, the Oxford dictionary definition is: “a person or thing that particularly annoys you and that you do not like”. Or if that all seems a bit high brow: “for fuck’s sake, not again”.
To piece this together I went off several loose criteria:
Sheer annoyance factor
Randomness factor
Ex factor
Trauma factor
It would have been very easy for this team to be all Crystal Palace or full of world class players, but that would defeat the personalisation of it all, and for this reason someone like Haaland doesn’t make the cut.
GK: Dean Henderson
Henderson just shades out Martin Dubravka (who kept five consecutive clean sheets against us) based on the annoyance factor. The sight of him alone just creates a flood of existential dread as he seems to play a blinder against us without fail. In appearances for Palace, he has played us eight times and lost just the once. During that time he’s shut us out at home in two particularly deflating cup defeats, but the memory that sticks out in my mind was being at Selhurst Park last season and his superb last minute save from Castagne to stop us getting a late win.
LB: Jeffrey Schlupp
While I said this wasn’t going to be all Palace, I can’t not put one of their left-backs in here. Take your pick, it could be Tyrick Mitchell with his double against us this year, or Ben Chilwell who came on and scored the winner, but in my opinion none qualify more than Jeffrey Schlupp, who bafflingly has scored three goals in eight appearances against us. This one might be bending the rules a bit as he was maybe playing slightly more advanced.
The first came in a balloon popping 0-2 defeat at the Cottage in August 2018 for our first home game back in the Premier League after four seasons, rifling it past the helpless Fabri and foreshadowing the bleak season ahead. He did it again at Selhurst Park a few months later in a 2-0 defeat, in a match I honestly can’t remember under Ranieri. Most annoying of the lot though, was his 87th-minute thunderbolt to equalise at the Cottage in 2024. Not again Jeffrey…
CB: Dan Burn
The lasting memory of Dan Burn in a Fulham shirt for Fulham fans will be him floundering at left-back in the game that sealed our relegation at the Britannia. Since leaving, he’s scored two against us in 12 appearances, impressive for a centre-back, and fortunately for us that didn’t become three last weekend. The first of his two was an away game on 16 December 2023 at St James’ Park. Newcastle were decimated by injuries and we fancied our chances, until Raul saw red at Lascelles’ dangerous elbow, and then actually saw red when his flying bum reduced us to 10 men. We lost 3-0, with Burn getting the third. Not one of my favourite away days.
Not content with that, Burn got his second a month later in the 0-2 FA Cup defeat at the Cottage in a match that marked the low point of fan relations with the owners over ticket prices, with the club letting Laura Woods know on live TV they weren’t worried about fan sentiment, but were in fact “very satisfied”. I don’t really mind players celebrating goals against former clubs, but he really doesn’t hold back at Craven Cottage - and deserves his place on the list.
CB: Gabriel
A little boring putting arguably the best CB in the league in here, but I’m going with Gabriel. Three goals and one assist in eight games against us is the kind of form we would dream of basically any player in our squad having right now, let alone a defender. The most annoying of which was probably a winner at the Emirates in 2022-23 after he had clumsily let Mitrovic in to put us ahead. He’s also chief wind up merchant, and quite an easy pick.
RB: Trent Alexander-Arnold
Another world-class pick but the outstanding candidate at right-back with two goals and two assists. Bobby De Cordova-Reid had put us in dreamland territory to go 3-2 up in the 80th minute at Anfield in 2023-24, only for Endo and then Trent to break our hearts with absolute screamers in the 87th and 88th minutes. Trent rubbed salt into the wound with a highlight reel-worthy free-kick at the Cottage later that season.
CM: Henri Lansbury
Probably the most rogue pick here, but Lansbury enjoyed playing against us more than any other team, with four goals and two assists in seven games. He scored two braces for Forest at the Cottage in consecutive seasons in the McCormack era.
If anyone was in the Johnny Haynes C or D during the 2014-15 game then they may remember a particularly angry Fulham fan giving him dog’s abuse for a good minute while he waited to take a free kick, to the extent that Lansbury turned around and started laughing at the guy, to this day I’m still perplexed at what made that man so angry… Of course, he then went on to score it before adding another. We held on to win that game 3-2, but Lansbury wasn’t done yet, scoring another brace and getting an assist in a 3-1 away win the following season to complete his revenge.
CM: John McGinn
The missed penalty this season was some much-needed levity on a player that has tormented us for a long time now. In 11 appearances he’s beaten us eight times, scoring twice and getting four assists in the process. That’s more goal contributions than he has against any other side in the Premier League, which is nice for him I guess. He knows how to play the opposition fanbase like a fiddle, and is seemingly everywhere all the time. He scored a wonderful goal from outside the box (who doesn’t?) last season in a painful 3-1 defeat at Villa Park, in which Silva lost his mind after more refereeing misfortune.
AM: Bruno Fernandes (c)
This team wouldn’t be complete without Bruno. Like McGinn he gave us a great comedy moment with his skied penalty last season. Fernandes has been the tormenter in chief, chalking up five goals and three assists in 13 appearances against us.
I had the misfortune of being at Old Trafford that fateful Sunday evening when Mitrovic became the most-wanted man in the country after politely trying to get Chris Kavanagh’s attention. Bruno converted the penalty to equalise, and later added a third for United in stoppage time. This game absolutely tops the traumatising memory list; it was a very long evening in Manchester.
Fast forward six months at the Cottage and our defenders repeatedly lost the ball in a game of hot potato, resulting in Bruno drilling in a 91st-minute winner. Every. Single. Time.
To his credit he seems happy to have a laugh with away fans when they sing “he looks like a rat”.
LW: Justin Kluivert
A last-minute Tony Khan special falling through due to a failed work permit on a niche technicality - pretty annoying isn’t it? That player signing for Bournemouth the next season and scoring in his first game against us in a 3-0 defeat that ruins your Boxing Day? That’s also pretty annoying. In his next game against us he puts one in the top corner in the 84th minute to put Bournemouth 2-1 up. It’s about as annoying as it gets.
(Full credit to Daft Limmy)
RW: Jacob Murphy
The man who inspired it all. We are Murphy’s favourite prey with five goals and four assists in 17 games, going back as early as 2014, when he put Blackpool 2-0 up at the Cottage, in a game we came back to draw 2-2 (I don’t remember it either). He added three further goal contributions against us in the Championship for Norwich and Sheffield Wednesday.
Quite an underrated player, but Murphy seems to turn into Arjen Robben against us, scoring in each of the past three seasons, including standout solo goals dribbling a great distance before hitting one past beyond a despairing Leno. He’s the epitome of a bête noire.
ST: Callum Wilson
This was a toss-up between Wilson and Nketiah, who has scored his last three domestic away goals at the Cottage, but I can’t think of another striker that gets under the skin in quite the same way as Wilson. He loves playing the heel, and seems to always get a rise. He’s scored four goals and one assist in 10 appearances, which means he’s not necessarily the most prolific but he’s also won seven times in the process.
Among the lowlights were his Fallon d’Floor entry after a small pull from Andersen outside the box, which wrongfully resulted in a penalty and a sending off for Andersen. It was a particularly bleak memory during the COVID season. To understand why Wilson earns his spot, isn’t so much about particular goals, but the centre of gravity he manages to command and how rarely we are on the right end of things.
Manager: Gary O’Neill
For some reason O’Neill has an impressive record against us with four wins, one draw and just one defeat. One of the worst of which was a painful 4-1 win for Wolves at Craven Cottage in late November in 2024. We were in great form, and up against a Wolves team in the relegation zone - and O’Neill’s job hanging on by a thread. We went on to lose it 4-1, in one of those games we just couldn’t ‘push on’ under Marco Silva. That game is perhaps rivalled by the recent defeat Portman Road this season, in a game that will perhaps be known as the Mami game in years to come. It my first away game of the season, and one we’d perhaps all rather forget.
Substitutes
Dubravka, Terry, Souček, Cunha, Benrahma, Semenyo, Nketiah






Cristiano Ronaldo. Has he ever played against us and not scored?
Cucurella. No obvious reason. Just annoying in the Bruno mould.