After Álvaro Arbeloa’s first few games in charge, the concern was about how on earth Fulham were going to keep goals out at one end of the pitch. Just a couple of weeks later, all of our conversation is revolving around the concept of how we’re going to score more at the other.
Much of that conversation has revolved around the striker’s position - and a schism has seemingly opened up between those who want to see Rodrigo Muniz starting games and those who are backing Gonzalo Garcia to come good. There are merits, I think, to both sides of that argument and both present imperfect solutions - but I also think we might need to have a little bit more of a conversation about where other goal threats are coming from in this team - because our striker debate would be far less of a head-rearing issue if we were finding goals from other spaces.
Talking on Wednesday’s podcast, Elizabeth and I were discussing the international break and in particular, the differing things that both Shea Charles and Hugo Larsson were asked to do at international level in their respective midfields as opposed to what we have seen them do at Fulham (and with the caveat that we have obviously seen Larsson have limited minutes thus far.)
We went down a rabbit hole on that, but it got me thinking about a comparison with last season, when the partnership of Sander Berge and Saša Lukić was slammed by many for being too defensive and not giving Marco Silva’s side enough thrust in the middle of the park. The solution at that time was the introduction of Alex Iwobi in a central role, which added to our creativity, but perhaps also meant we were more susceptible to attacks (particularly in transition) through the middle.
What’s interesting this time round is that after Larsson scored for Sweden against Poland, and Charles was instrumental in a more attacking sense as Northern Ireland drew and were promoted in Budapest, is that both midfielders were being fielded as part of a double pivot - Larsson alongside Jesper Karlström in a 4-4-2, and Charles alongside Trai Hume in a 3-4-2-1.
Neither of these formations are what Arbeloa has used, but in some ways that doesn’t matter - what we are seeing is that both players are capable of bursting forwards and making a difference in the final third. And that gives us a chance to examine if we can actually ask for a little bit more from our midfield in that regard.
This article was originally going to be about the way that Shea Charles had fitted in seamlessly to Premier League life since joining from Southampton into the summer - he already looks hugely at home at this level, but given Adam wrote such a lovely piece praising him last time out, and that we need to find some more juice from our midfield, I pivoted.
But Shea will remain the focus, given that he is clearly ahead of Larsson in the pecking order at the moment. I’ve picked out a few statistics here about Charles to compare quickly what he’s doing at international level to what we’re seeing from our number 19 at the Cottage.
I pulled some comparative data from what Charles has been doing for club and country in the opening games of this season - six games in the Nations League for Northern Ireland, 10 games in the Premier League for Fulham - adjusted it so it was per 90 minutes played, and the results are pretty striking. The first graph (on the left) is the raw numbers for five metrics (shots taken, shots on target, expected assists, key passes and crosses) per 90 minutes, and the second is the comparative percentiles for each statistic - against players in a similar position in the same competition.
It should be noted before we go any further: this is not in any way a criticism of Shea Charles’ performances for Fulham - to echo AF, he has been a Rolls Royce of a footballer since arriving in SW6 and in highlighting the differences here, I am suggesting only that I think there is more to come from him in an offensive sense going forward if Arbeloa chooses to go down that route.
You will see though that for Northern Ireland, not only is Charles outperforming his work at Fulham in each of these categories, but barring expected assists (which is a low threshold because of the position group anyway), he is above the 60th percentile for players in each whilst playing for country; and yet below the 50th percentile whilst playing for his club.
Much of this can be explained by the nature of his role. Arbeloa is clearly asking Charles to be much more of a shield than being the man to try and prise the opposition open; but in doing so he appears to be limiting what our man in the middle is capable of in a more offensive sense.
And in watching both Charles and Larsson in the last week, I have come to wonder if the extra thrust we need in the final third to start to break teams open more efficiently; might not be a personnel issue (as it appeared to be with Sander and Saša under Marco), but actually just taking the handbrake off our second midfielder in the pivot and allowing them to be more involved in the final third.
There have been flashes already - Charles’s beautiful, subtle little flick to Cesar Palacios in the buildup to Muniz’s goal against Newcastle was a moment of class in the chaos; but if the overloads are going to be more effective, perhaps we need to see more of his box-crashing abilities from the outset, rather than when we are simply chasing a game late on.
Arbeloa has shown us he can find adjustments to his system already this season in his quick pivot away from our chaotic lack of a rest defence and in keeping one of the full-backs along the backline to help with defending in transition. Perhaps just giving a bit more licence to roam in the midfield might find us that elusive balance that we’ve been craving between being hard to beat, and finding it hard to score goals.





I would like to see garcia on the wing,and Rodrigo CF for 3 or 4 games not saying it will work but worth a shot .
Nice use of comparative data to make the point. Charles has been a great addition and the eye test also supports your contention that he could add more to our attacking threat. Especially, as our defense is building in confidence and accumulating minutes together. But having a focal point through the middle, like Muniz, will still be sorely missing. I’d love to see him at City AND Charles being a bit more adventurous. Muniz thrives in chaos and having more attacking possibilities increases his chances and ours as a club.